Laser Beam Welding VS Electron Beam Welding

As the name suggests, beam welding uses various beams to weld metal parts. Two kinds of beam welding are prevalent in today’s world. Laser beam welding uses a focused laser beam to do this job. On the other hand, electron beam welding uses a stream of electrons to induce heat for welding. Both methods have the same purpose, but the beam sources differ.

Beam welding is better than traditional welding for several reasons. First, it is more accurate. Second, it generates a concentrated heat that melts the target area, so it doesn’t affect the surrounding areas as much. Third, it is faster and more efficient.

LBW, or laser beam welding, is one of the most commonly used welding techniques. It is used in electronics, jewelry, and many advanced manufacturing plants. It employs a very slender laser beam as the heat source to melt and bond various materials. In one single sentence, LBW is accurate, fast, and versatile. It works not only on metals but also on other materials.

Usually, there are three primary laser sources: fiber, Nd: YAG, and CO2 laser. Each of these lasers has its unique pros and cons. However, whatever the type, these sources produce a focused light beam for welding. Later, with the help of a laser gun, it is focused on the workpiece.

When the laser strikes the material, the extreme heat fuses part of the material at the weld joint. It fuses at high temperatures and cools rapidly to give good adhesion. The operator moves along the weld joint, and the process continues. This is a very efficient way of welding materials without producing any gases or radiation.

Laser beam welding can further be divided into two types: pulsed and continuous. Pulsed laser welding generally uses short bursts of laser energy. Each pulse here melts a small area of the material. This welding method is ideal for thin materials. On the other hand, CW laser welding emits a steady laser beam. It is typically used for deep penetration of thicker metals.

1. Laser beam welding, unlike EBW, has relatively low capital costs. Compared to other processes, it has short cycles and doesn’t require vacuum chambers or enclosures. All these benefits guarantee that LBW reduces the general cost of a given project.
2. Laser beam welding does not need complex tooling.
3. This method also produces less HAZ or heat-affected zones.
4. One of the best things about laser beam welding is its scalability.
5. Laser beam welding needs lower training costs.
6. This method doesn’t produce any X-rays. So, this method is safe and reliable.

1. Laser beam welding can not offer deep penetration. In general, it provides for welding up to -1 inch.
2. Laser beam welding behaves differently for different types of metals. This becomes an issue, especially when working with reflective materials.

Electron beam welding generates heat in the same way as laser welding. However, the source of the beam is different. This method uses a stream of high-velocity electrons to melt a workpiece. In general, there are three types of electron beam welding.

The most common method is thermal electron beam welding, which uses electron beams to melt metals in a vacuum chamber. Cold electron beam welding, on the other hand, doesn’t involve heating. It directly breaks the molecules and bonds of metals. Resistance electron beam welding passes an electric current through two metal parts. The current typically creates a resistance in between the parts and produces heat. This heat melts the metals and helps in welding.

In general, electron beam welding uses an electron gun that emits a stream of high-speed electrons. This whole process is done in a vacuum chamber. During the process, the electron strikes the material. When it hits the materials, the kinetic energy converts into heat. The intense heat melts and fuses the materials. This process is ideal for deep and narrow welding. The best part is that it significantly reduces the distortion.

1. Since electron beam welding is done in a vacuum chamber, there is no chance of gas contamination.
2. Electron beam welding’s best feature is its deep penetration capacity. This method’s aspect ratio is also very high compared to laser beam welding.
3. Electron beam welding is also independent of energy absorption. This means EBW doesn’t depend on the material’s ability to absorb energy.
4. There’s no restriction on reflective or dissimilar metals. You can weld all sorts of metals under an electron beam welding machine.

1. Electron beam welding needs high initial costs. Compared to laser beam welding, these machines are expensive. Besides, the setup cost is very high, including chamber and tooling costs.
2. Electron beam welding produces X-rays and radiation. Therefore, it is done in a very controlled environment.
3. Also, electron beam welding is limited by part sizes. This machine cannot weld more significant parts unless the chamber is big enough to hold them.
4. Since this process requires a very controlled environment and expert hands, beginners may be unable to do it properly.

You have already gone through the basics of beam welding. Now you know the strengths and weaknesses of each method discussed above. Finally, let us look at the main differences between these two beam welding processes. You can find out which method might be better for your project.

Electron beam welding makes deeper penetration than laser beam welding. It can weld thick materials in a single pass. Generally, you can achieve a deep weld of up to 3 inches. A higher-power EBW machine can offer you more results.

In contrast, laser beam welding is more suitable for welding thinner or medium-thickness materials. In general, you can achieve deep welds of up to 1 inch.

Electron beam welding requires a vacuum chamber, making the setup even more challenging and time-consuming. Laser beam welding doesn’t need a vacuum, so it requires simpler equipment. You can use it in the open air or indoors. Wherever you use it, LBW is safe and easy to set up.

In many cases, laser beam welding is faster than electron beam welding. Laser beam welding is characterized by relatively fast and accurate welding. Electron beam welding, in this case, may take a long time. Every time, you will have to set up the vacuum environment. This generally adds extra time; thus, EBW is slower than LBW.

However, there are a few points that you have to remember When it comes to the degree of efficiency. Electron beam welding is energy-intensive for deeper and more accurate welding. It may be efficient for deep penetration welding but less efficient than laser beam welding.

Finally, the most critical factor for every business is cost. Electron beam welding equipment is more costly than other types of equipment. Because of the vacuum involved, operating expenses are high. Laser beam welding is cheaper and easier to maintain than electron beam welding. However, if you choose high-power lasers, that might still be costly.

You have gone through a comprehensive analysis between laser beam welding and electron beam welding. You now know that both methods have unique advantages and limitations. Let’s summarize the whole content one more time. The table below highlights the key difference between these two methods.

If you have any questions about laser devices, please contact us. HantenCNC also produces a wide range of laser cutting, marking, cleaning, and welding machines. You are always welcome to our customer support portal.